Credit Card vs. Rental Company Insurance: Which One Protects You Better?

December 3, 2025

}

Mins

Credit Card vs. Rental Company Insurance: Which One Protects You Better?

Many people renting a car assume their credit card automatically covers everything.
But is that really true?

If you’re exploring car rentals in Columbia SC, this guide helps you compare both options so you know exactly what you’re protected from.

Credit Card Coverage: What It Usually Includes

Credit card insurance often provides:

  • Collision protection (secondary)
  • Theft protection
  • Some damage coverage

But it usually DOESN’T cover:

  • Liability
  • Injury to others
  • Glass damage
  • Tires and rims
  • Loss of use fees
  • Administrative fees

Rental Company Insurance: What It Covers

Depending on what you choose, rental insurance can include:

  • Full collision coverage
  • Liability protection
  • Theft coverage
  • Personal accident coverage
  • Coverage for glass and tires (in premium packages)

This means fewer gaps and fewer out-of-pocket surprises.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureCredit CardRental Company
Collision coverageYesYes
Liability❌ No✔ Yes
Tires/Windshield❌ No✔ With premium
Damage fees❌ Often excluded✔ Included
Loss of use❌ Often denied✔ Included
Payout speedSlowFast

Which Is Better?

If you’re looking for cheap auto rentals in Columbia SC, credit card coverage can save you money but only if you understand its limits.

For peace of mind, especially on long trips, rental company insurance is more complete.

Trending Posts